Ask Aurelia: How to Manage “Is It Real?!” Questions About Moissanite

Reader Question

One of the most common concerns we hear from moissanite lovers is how to handle awkward or skeptical questions about their rings. Recently, one of our readers sent in a great question about this:

Here’s the email:

Hi Mehedi,

I absolutely love my moissanite engagement ring, but sometimes I feel a little self-conscious about it. I worry that people will assume it’s fake or ask me outright if it’s a diamond. I don’t want to lie, but I also don’t want to get into a debate every time someone notices my ring.

How do you recommend handling these situations?

Thanks for your help!
— Evelyn

Great question, Evelyn!

This is something a lot of moissanite owners wonder about. The truth is, moissanite is a real gemstone—just like diamonds, sapphires, or rubies. It’s not fake, and you’re not “fooling” anyone by choosing it.

That said, dealing with the occasional “Is it real?” or “Is that a diamond?” can feel tricky. Let’s break down some practical, confidence-boosting ways to handle these situations.

Why Do People Ask If Your Moissanite Is Real?

Some people ask simply because they’re unfamiliar with moissanite. Others assume that any large, sparkling gemstone must be a diamond. And then there are those (let’s be honest—rude ones) who seem to be testing you or fishing for a reaction.

One Reddit user put it best:

“I’ve had one person ask if my ring is real, and I just said, ‘Well, I don’t think I’m imagining it!’ That shut them down pretty fast.”

The truth is, moissanite is a real gemstone—just like sapphire, emerald, or ruby. It’s not a knockoff or a “fake” diamond. The only difference? It has its own unique beauty, fiery brilliance, and ethical benefits.

Most people won’t question your ring at all—they’ll just notice how stunning it looks. And if someone does ask, how you respond is entirely up to you.

Understanding What “Real” Means

Moissanite is a real gemstone—just like sapphire, ruby, or emerald. Some people assume that because it’s lab-created, it must be synthetic, like cubic zirconia. But that’s a common misconception—moissanite has its own distinct chemical structure and brilliance, making it a genuine, high-quality gemstone.

Just because a gemstone is created in a lab doesn’t mean it’s any less valuable. In fact, buying moissanite instead of a diamond offers a range of benefits, from ethical sourcing to superior fire and brilliance. And when it comes to durability, moissanite ranks just below diamonds on the Mohs scale, making it an excellent choice for an engagement ring or everyday wear.

Another misconception is that moissanite lacks quality standards. But just like diamonds, moissanite is graded based on cut, clarity, and color. If you’re curious about what sets a GRA-certified moissanite ring apart, you’ll find that reputable sellers provide certification to verify authenticity.

When choosing a gemstone, it’s essential to focus on quality, not outdated myths. The idea that diamonds are the only “real” option is an outdated marketing narrative. If you’re interested in how moissanite’s brilliance, fire, and durability compare, check out the 4Cs of moissanite to see how it holds up against traditional diamonds.

At the end of the day, real isn’t about whether a stone was mined or lab-created—it’s about its beauty, durability, and the joy it brings. Don’t let outdated myths about moissanite dictate your decision.

Confident Responses to the “Is It Real?” Question

We’ve all been there—someone takes a glance at your ring and hits you with the “Is it real?” question. Whether they’re genuinely curious, assuming it’s a diamond, or just being judgmental, here are some perfect responses to keep you feeling confident and in control.

For the Friendly, Curious Person

Some people have never heard of moissanite, and their question comes from pure curiosity. A great way to introduce them to this incredible gemstone is:

“It’s actually moissanite! It’s a stunning, ethical, and more affordable alternative to a diamond.”
“Yes! It’s moissanite—one of the most brilliant gemstones out there.”

Want to show them how moissanite stacks up against diamonds? You can share how moissanite sparkles even more thanks to its higher refractive index.

For the Rude or Judgy Person

Let’s be real—some people just want to be nosy or test you. The best response? Confidence.

“It’s as real as it gets! Moissanite is an amazing gemstone in its own right.”
“Well, I don’t think I’m imagining it!” (A witty, lighthearted comeback.)

If they push further, you can always educate them on where moissanite comes from—it was first discovered in meteorites! That’s way cooler than an earth-mined diamond.

For Someone Who Assumes It’s a Diamond

Many people automatically assume that a dazzling, colorless gem must be a diamond. You can set the record straight without taking offense:

“It’s actually moissanite—most people can’t tell the difference!”
“Nope, not a diamond! Moissanite sparkles even more.”

And they’re not wrong to mistake it for a diamond—moissanite is one of the best diamond alternatives out there. Plus, if they’re wondering how it compares in size and weight, the moissanite weight vs. diamond comparison will blow their mind.

At the end of the day, confidence is key. Whether your moissanite ring was chosen for its ethics, affordability, or superior sparkle, own it—because you know you made the smarter choice!

Owning Your Choice with Confidence

Here’s the truth—moissanite isn’t just a “diamond alternative”; it’s a breathtaking gemstone with its own unique brilliance and charm. If you’ve chosen moissanite, it’s because you appreciate its beauty, value, and everything it stands for.

Many people are still unaware of how moissanite is made or what makes it so special. Unlike cubic zirconia or other diamond simulants, moissanite is a real, durable gemstone that rivals diamonds in sparkle and toughness. In fact, moissanite under UV light glows in a way that even diamonds don’t!

Ethical and Eco-Friendly Choice

If you chose moissanite because of its ethical and environmental benefits, that’s something to be proud of. Unlike mined diamonds, moissanite is created in controlled environments, avoiding the environmental destruction and ethical concerns tied to traditional diamond mining.

Budget-Savvy & Smart Investment

Many people switch to moissanite because of its incredible value—you get a stunning, near-indistinguishable gem at a fraction of the cost.

Curious about pricing? Check out this moissanite price comparison to see how much you can save without sacrificing beauty.

At the end of the day, the only opinion that truly matters is yours. If someone questions your choice, own it with confidence—because you’ve chosen a gem that’s just as dazzling, more ethical, and way more budget-friendly than a diamond!

What If You Want People to Think It’s a Diamond?

That’s totally fine! Your ring is yours, and you don’t owe anyone an explanation. If someone compliments your ring, a simple “Thank you!” is more than enough. You’re not obligated to clarify what it is—unless you want to!

The truth is, moissanite is so visually similar to diamonds that most people wouldn’t know the difference unless you told them. Even side-by-side comparisons show just how close they look. In certain lighting, moissanite even outshines diamonds, as you can see in this diamond vs. moissanite in sunlight comparison.

If you’re curious about how moissanite stacks up against diamonds, here’s a quick breakdown:

Moissanite vs. Diamond: Key Differences

For a more detailed breakdown, check out this moissanite vs. diamond comparison.

At the end of the day, your ring is about what makes YOU happy. Whether you openly share that it’s moissanite or let others assume it’s a diamond, the choice is entirely yours.

Final Thoughts – Be Proud of Your Moissanite!

At the end of the day, moissanite is an incredible gemstone—it’s durable, sparkly, and stunning. Whether you’re rocking a gorgeous moissanite engagement ring or a custom loose moissanite stone, you don’t need to justify your choice to anyone. It’s all about what makes you feel good.

So, next time someone asks “Is it real?” just smile and answer however feels right for you. Moissanite is real—in every sense of the word! If you’re proud of your choice, that confidence will shine brighter than any stone.

What’s your go-to response when people ask about your moissanite jewelry? Drop a comment below!

As always, feel free to reach out with any more gemstone questions. I love hearing from readers like you!